Court of Appeals of Minnesota July 17, 1990, No. CX-90-198 (Demers v. City of Minneapolis)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-07-1990

lead-opinion

OPINION

KALITOWSKI, Judge.

Appellant City of Minneapolis challenges the judgment requiring it to allow respondent David Demers to inspect nonpending and noncurrent police department internal affairs complaint forms without charge. The city argues the Minnesota Government Data Practices Act and policy considerations require that complainants’ names be protected and not subject to public disclosure.

FACTS

David Demers is a graduate student in the social sciences at the University of Minnesota. In March 1989, he wrote a letter to Minneapolis Police Chief John Laux requesting copies of or access to internal affairs complaint forms filed during the past ten years, excluding current or pending complaints, and the final dispositions or determinations of these complaints.

Chief Laux referred Demers’ letter to the Minneapolis city attorney’s office. An assistant city attorney informed Demers that because his request involved the retrieval and copying of about 1,764 files, he would be charged approximately $1,500. In addition, Demers was notified that certain information on the complaint forms was not public information under the Minnesota Government Data Practices Act. After seeking clarification of what portions were not public, Demers was informed that he would be denied access to information regarding complainants’ identities based upon Minn.Stat. § 13.43 and the 1987 Minnesota Supreme Court case of Erickson v. MacArthur, 414 N.W.2d 406 (Minn. 1987).

A further exchange of letters resulted in an offer from the city to supply Demers with the requested complaint forms but with all information deemed private by the city blocked out. Demers was also notified that before he could receive any information, he must supply the city with a certified check in the amount of $2,322.50 to cover costs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.