Supreme Court of New Hampshire December 28, 1990, No. 88-434 (State v. Menard)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-12-1990

Brock, C.J.

The defendant, Jerry D. Menard, was convicted after trial by jury of two counts of aggravated felonious sexual assault on a victim of less than thirteen years of age, RSA 632-A:2, XI. On appeal, he claims that the Superior Court (DiClerico, J.) erred in admitting the testimony of a rebuttal witness and in failing to exclude hearsay statements made by the witness during that testimony. For the reasons which follow, we affirm.

The defendant was indicted and tried on two counts of aggravated felonious sexual assault. Both indictments were based upon the complaint of a young female victim who alleged that, on August 18,1987, the defendant lured her into his apartment, threatened her with a knife and committed the sexual assaults on her.

During trial, the defendant’s mother, Ruth Partlow, testified on behalf of her son. On cross-examination, the prosecutor asked Mrs. Partlow about a conversation she might have had with Timothy Crotts, a Claremont police detective. Although Mrs. Partlow acknowledged meeting Detective Crotts while “trying to get [the defendant] bailed at the County Farm,” she denied having told him what she thought had happened between the victim and the defendant, stating that she “didn’t discuss anything like that with him.” She also testified that she had never discussed the charge of sexual assault with the defendant.

Immediately following Mrs. Partlow’s testimony, the defense rested and the State called Detective Crotts as a rebuttal witness. Although the record reflects that a discussion took place prior to Detective Crotts’ testimony at the initiation of defense counsel, no objection to Detective Crotts’ testimony was placed on the record during the jury trial. Following the unrecorded discussion, the prosecutor examined Detective Crotts, who testified that he plainly remembered a conversation, in which either Mrs. Partlow or her boyfriend, Mr. Dunbar, said: “That little slut seduced him. He didn’t do anything to her.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.