West Virginia Court of Claims July 18, 1990, CC-89-386 (Holcomb v. Department of Highways)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-07-1990

PER CURIAM:

*70Claimants are the owners of property located in Richwood, Nicholas County, West Virginia. Claimants' property sustained flood damage in August 1989. claimants allege that the flooding resulted from respondent's negligent maintenance of certain culverts located on W.Va. Route 76, also known as the "CC Road", which road is above claimants' property. Claimants allege damages in the amount of $3,267.74.

Respondent contends that the culverts were cleaned and maintained in accordance with regular maintenance procedures and that the flooding was the result of an unusual amount of rainfall which occurred the night prior to the flood on claimants' property.

Claimants' testimony described the flood which occurred at approximately 7:00 to 8:00 a.m. on August 21, 1989. claimants observed water flowing onto their property "like a river." The water flooded the basement level of the house and the garage. The basement was finished and carpeted. Claimants telephoned neighbors for assistance. It was determined that the culvert above claimants' property was clogged completely. Claimant Steve Holcomb, with the assistance of neighbors, cleaned it out so that water could flow through it. They also dug a ditch and piled rocks in front of the basement wall to attempt to divert the water. However, water seeped through the blocks and flooded the basement. The carpet was damaged from the mud and water as was a wall mural. The walls were stained by the muddy water and required repainting. The water also washed gravel from claimants' driveway.

During the flood one of the respondent's employees, Raymond R. Tolley, a crew leader for respondent, came to claimants' residence. He observed three culverts blocked with rocks and debris which are located above claimants' property. Mr. Holcomb explained that respondent had cleaned these same culverts two to three months prior to the flooding when excess water had flowed onto claimants' property during a hard rain.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.