West Virginia Court of Claims August 2, 1990, CC-86-440 (Fatony v. Division of Highways)
Also known as
United States · · · 02-08-1990
BAKER, JUDGE:
Claimant is the owner of real property located in Glover, Wyoming County, West Virginia. The front of the property is adjacent to W. Va. Route 97 and the back of the property is adjacent to Rose Street. Claimant and her husband purchased this property in 1958. In the early 1970's, they added a basement to the house. Respondent performed construction work on W.Va. Route 97 in 1984-85. After this construction, claimant alleges that unusual amounts of water began draining onto the property. This water has caused the ground beneath the house to remain wet all year-round resulting in structural damage to the house and has caused claimant to abandon the use of the basement due to constant water problems in the basement. Claimant also alleges that the bank at the front of the house has not been maintained property by respondent causing an unsightly condition. Claimant seeks damages for the structural problems and the drainage in the amount of $18,000.00.
The evidence revealed that claimant and her husband, who is now deceased, entered *75into a right-of-way agreement with respondent in 1982. Respondent purchased a portion of the front yard for widening the shoulder and the surface of Route 97. Prior to the construction, there was an open drainage area from the front to the back of claimant's property which had been placed there by claimant's husband shortly after they had moved onto the property. It was claimant's understanding that there would be no open ditches in her yard after the construction.
During the construction which took place on Route 97, respondent came upon a "swamp" area. It was necessary for respondent to alleviate this condition in order to provide a stable base for the new road. Respondent placed large boulders for the base of the road and provided a drainage structure at the swamp area. A two-foot lift of rock was placed for the roadbed and seven or eight inches of asphalt was laid.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit