U S Air Force Court of Military Review October 30, 1990, ACM 28341 (United States v. Shoup)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-10-1990

*821DECISION

LEONARD, Senior Judge:

Appellant asserts two errors for our consideration. First, he maintains that he was prejudiced by the trial counsel improperly arguing facts that were not in evidence. Second, he alleges that he was denied procedural due process with regard to the pretrial processing of his case. We find error, but no prejudice.

During his sentencing argument in a trial before military judge alone, trial counsel argued the following:

This is the third drug case you have heard this week; there were many before and there will be many more in the future ...

* * * * * *

Over twenty people died in Panama a few weeks ago trying to stop drugs from coming into this country.

There were no facts in evidence to support either argument and there was no objection to either argument by the trial defense counsel.

We find that trial counsel’s argument was an improper comment on facts that were not in evidence. United States v. Clifton, 15 M.J. 26 (C.M.A.1983); United States v. Shows, 5 M.J. 892 (A.F.C.M.R.1978). However, we hold that trial defense counsel’s failure to object to the argument waived appellate review of this issue. R.C.M. 1001(g). Further, even if the issue were not waived, we would find no prejudice in this judge alone trial before an experienced trial judge.

In his second assertion of error, appellant maintains that the manner in which the government processed his Request for Discharge in Lieu of Trial by Court-Martial resulted in a denial of procedural due process that should invalidate the referral of his charges. The basis for this allegation of error is twofold.

First, he alleges that the government improperly delayed processing of his charges so that his request for discharge could be denied by the special court-martial convening authority, who also served as appellant’s unit commander, instead of being sent to the general court-martial convening authority for action.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.