Alexandria County Circuit Court June 19, 1990, Case No. (Law) CL 900066 (Whitley v. Connolly)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-06-1990

By JUDGE JAMES W. HALEY, JR.

This aspect of complex litigation comes before the court upon defendant John P. Connolly’s demurrer to that portion of the Motion for Judgment alleging malicious prosecution attributable to him.

For purposes of this demurrer, the parties have stipulated:

(1) That on or about October 1, 1988, John P. Connolly appeared before a magistrate in Alexandria, Virginia, gave sworn evidence before the magistrate, and the magistrate issued a warrant charging plaintiff with a violation on that date of § 18.2-427, a misdemeanor involving telephone threats, and

(2) That subsequent thereto, the plaintiff was convicted on the warrant of a violation of § 18.2-427 by the General District Court of the City of Alexandria, and

(3) That the conviction aforesaid was appealed and, in accordance with Virginia criminal procedure, was tried de novo on May 23, 1989, by the Circuit Court of the City of Alexandria, which court found the plaintiff not guilty of a violation of § 18.2-427.

Those paragraphs of the Motion for Judgment pertinent to the issue raised herein are as follows:

*42625. Defendant J. Connolly instituted the . . . criminal proceeding without probable cause

26. Defendant J. Connolly acted intentionally maliciously, willfully, and/or with callous disregard for the plaintiff’s rights ....

53. Defendant J. Connolly . . . [acted] . . . intentionally, willfully, with malice, and/or with callous disregard for the plaintiff’s rights ....

In Donahoe Construction Co., Inc. v. Mount Vernon Associates, 235 Va. 531, 540, 369 S.E.2d 857, 862 (1988), the Supreme Court concisely stated:

An action for malicious prosecution ... is based upon an underlying criminal proceeding maliciously instituted without probable cause, which terminated in a manner not unfavorable to the plaintiff. Pallas v. Zaharopoulous, 219 Va. 751, 754, 250 S.E.2d 357, 359 (1979). Thomas A. Bain, III v. Nelson S. Phillips, Jr., 217 Va. 387, 393, 228 S.E.2d 576, 581 (1976).

In Lee v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.