Richmond County Circuit Court November 2, 1990, Case No. LR-4024-1 (Chatman v. IPCO Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-11-1990

BY JUDGE MELVIN R. HUGHES, JR.

Defendant IPCO Corporation filed a Demurrer to the Amended Motion for Judgment, which was filed after the Court sustained IPCO’s Demurrer to the original Motion for Judgment.

Plaintiff brings this action against three dentists and IPCO, trading as Sterling Dental Center, alleging dental malpractice and damages in the improper fitting of a dental appliance. In the first motion for judgment, the only mention of IPCO was as part owner of Sterling Dental Center and as a national chain which leases to and contracts with dentists to provide, according to the pleading, "in house" practice. Otherwise, the first pleading alleged all the defendants were "jointly and severally negligent individually and as agents and employees of Sterling Dental Center." Deeming these allegations insufficient to make a claim of malpractice against IPCO directly or any claim vicariously, the Court sustained the first demurrer. Now in the Amended Motion for Judgment, plaintiff alleges (1) IPCO was involved in a joint enterprise with the defendant dentists under the trade name Sterling Dental Center, (2) the dentists were agents of IPCO, the owner, (3) IPCO pressed the dentists in their work causing them to be negligent, and (4) IPCO itself provided dental service to plaintiff without a license to practice dentistry.

*105IPCO states that being unlicensed, it "cannot be guilty of malpractice" because it is not "a health care provider" as defined in § 8.01-581.1, Code of Virginia of 1950, as amended, the Virginia Medical Malpractice Act § 8.01-581.1, et seq. (the Act). In support of the "health care provider" argument, IPCO relies on Richman v. National Health Laboratories, 235 Va. 353 (1988). IPCO also demurs on the ground that maintaining an oppressive work environment is not a cause of action, and there is no dentist-patient relationship alleged as to it.

The Court finds that the Demurrer is not sustainable this time on any ground.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.