Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit December 18, 1990, No. 87-1844 (Napeahi v. Paty)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-12-1990
HUG, Circuit Judge:
This action concerns an alleged breach of trust by the State of Hawaii in the manner in which the state officials defined the shoreline of a parcel of privately owned real property. The state official’s certification of the high water mark of the ocean waves along the shoreline of the parcel resulted in including 1.75 acres within the boundary of the privately owned parcel, rather than as submerged land held by the State in trust for the people of Hawaii.
*899I.
Overview
The State of Hawaii, under the act that admitted it to statehood, holds certain lands that were ceded to it by the United States in trust for particular uses and purposes. One of those purposes is “for the betterment of the conditions of native Hawaiians.” Mervin Napeahi, in his capacity as a native Hawaiian and a beneficiary of that trust, brought this action for breach of trust against the Director of the Department of Land and Natural Resources for the State of Hawaii in his official capacity. The complaint sought injunctive and declaratory relief.
Napeahi contends that by abandoning to a private landowner approximately 1.75 acres of tidal land, which he claims is ceded trust land, the State of Hawaii has breached the trust. In contrast, the director, who is charged with the administration of the trust, maintains that the disputed area is private property rather than ceded public land. After a six-day trial, the district judge found that the area was private land and entered judgment for the director. The principal issue in this appeal is whether the district judge erred in finding that the director was correct in concluding that the area in contention is private land.
This case varies from the usual Hawaiian shoreline dispute in that it is not a contest between the State and a private landowner of sea coast land as to the seaward boundary. In this case, the State and the landowner agree.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit