New Mexico Court of Appeals June 4, 1991, 12422 (State v. Hoeffel)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-06-1991

OPINION

HARTZ, Judge.

Defendant appeals from his conviction of embezzling from his landlady furniture of a value in excess of $250. He claims that (1) the district court erred in excluding evidence relating to prior civil litigation between defendant and his landlady and (2) the verdict must be reversed because of insufficient proof of the value of the furniture and of his criminal intent. We affirm. EVIDENCE OF THE CIVIL SUIT

The allegation that defendant had appropriated furniture from the house he was renting from his landlady was aired in civil litigation predating defendant’s criminal trial. Defendant was the plaintiff in the civil action. The basis of his claim was that the landlady had improperly seized his personal belongings pursuant to a landlord’s lien. The landlady counterclaimed. One of her claims was that defendant had removed furniture from the house without her permission.

Approximately two months before defendant’s criminal trial the judge in the civil suit issued a letter expressing his opinion on the issues before him. One paragraph of the six-page letter considered the landlady’s claim regarding the furniture. The judge wrote: “I find that [the landlady] has failed to establish by a preponderance of the evidence that she has sustained a loss by virtue of any removal [of furniture] and that such removal was without her permission. The claim for recovery for the alleged removal of the items is denied.”

On the day of the criminal trial the district court heard argument by the parties regarding the admissibility in the criminal trial of the letter opinion in the civil case. Defense counsel contended that the letter was admissible to discredit the landlady’s credibility and to show her motive and bias. The prosecutor conceded that some aspects of the civil litigation might be admissible, see State v. Santillanes, 86 N.M. 627, 526 P.2d 424 (Ct.App.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.