Court of Civil Appeals of Oklahoma June 17, 1991, 69148 (RJB Gas Pipeline Co. v. Colorado Interstate Gas Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-06-1991
HANSEN, Presiding Judge:
This case involves claims brought by RJB Gas Pipeline Company (RJB) against Colorado Interstate Gas Company (CIG) for breach of the provisions of four gas purchase agreements under which RJB gathers and sells, and CIG purchases natural gas.
The gas is sold under four contracts designated as Nos. 535, 669, 704, and 840. The contracts have four principal provisions:
1. For the gas itself, CIG agrees to pay the highest price in eastern Colorado, or the applicable price established by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (the FERC), whichever is greater;
2. For gathering, CIG agrees to pay $.20 per Mcf or any higher price prescribed by the FERC;
3. CIG agrees to take, or pay for if not taken, a certain minimum “Contract Quantity” of gas per year; and
4. If CIG pays for the deficiency between the Contract Quantity and any lesser quantity of gas actually taken, it can make up the deficiency payment by taking free gas within the ensuing five years.
In April, 1984, RJB brought suit seeking actual and punitive damages for CIG’s alleged failure to pay a gathering fee as set forth in the four contracts. RJB amended its petition to assert additional claims that CIG had breached the take-or-pay provisions of contracts # 535, 669 and 704. RJB also sought punitive damages for alleged tortious conduct on the part of CIG in failing to make the take-or-pay payments.
CIG answered denying any liability for payment of the gathering fee based on certain orders of the FERC. It defended the take or pay action by claiming the contract allowed recoupment.
The court entered partial summary judgment as to liability for RJB on its gathering claim. The case proceeded to trial on the gathering damages, take-or-pay, and punitive damage claims. At the end of the evidence, the court directed a verdict for RJB on the gathering claims in the amount of $2,291,397.67.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit