Ohio Court of Appeals January 17, 1991, No. 6-89-10. (Joseph v. Wyss)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-01-1991

*201

Miller, Judge.

This is an appeal by plaintiffs-appellants from a judgment of the Court of Common Pleas of Hardin County.

Plaintiffs-appellants, Robert L. Joseph et al., brought their action asserting that defendant-appellee, Ronald D. Wyss, had constructed a force pump and pipeline system across his land and the lands of defendants-appellees, Mike Rose and Judy Rose, to carry water from Wyss’ 75.5 acre tract to the Price Ditch, which ditch drains the lands of plaintiffs-appellants, but does not naturally drain the lands of Wyss, and that this extra and additional amount of water thereby placed in the Price Ditch kept the water in that ditch at a high and flooded condition for an unnaturally long period of time, backing water up on the fields of plaintiffs, drowning out their crops, blowing out tile and water control devices established by plaintiffs on their fields and deteriorating the fertility of the soil of plaintiffs.

Plaintiffs sought damages from defendants, as well as injunctive relief preventing defendants from maintaining the pump and pipeline system and to remove the same.

Defendants basically denied the allegations of the complaint with defendant Wyss also setting forth several affirmative defenses.

The issues of causation and existence of damages were tried to a jury and the issue of injunctive relief to the court simultaneously.

The jury returned a verdict for defendants on the damage issues upon which the trial court rendered judgment and the trial court denied injunctive relief.

The record before this court consists of the transcript of docket and journal entries, original papers and a partial transcript of proceedings containing proceedings out of the presence of the jury regarding requests for instructions, the trial court’s instructions to the jury and proceedings out of the presence of the jury concerning special interrogatories to the jury.

Plaintiffs-appellants set forth five assignments of error in their appeal.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.