Ohio Court of Appeals June 24, 1991, No. 58614. (Nationwide Mutual Insurance v. MacHniak)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-06-1991

Patton, Judge.

On May 31, 1986, appellant Cheryl Machniak was struck by an automobile operated by Robert Jarrells. It is uncontroverted that immediately prior to appellant’s injury, Jarrells was involved in an altercation with Daniel Maxwell, who was operating the vehicle in which appellant was a passenger. The fight arose out of a dispute involving a mutual girlfriend. According to Jarrells’ deposition testimony, the fight did not involve appellant and he had no intention of harming her. Following an initial altercation, Jarrells continued to pursue the Maxwell vehicle in his own automobile. Apparently, the

*640

appellant fell to the ground as she attempted to exit from the Maxwell vehicle. However, the exact cause of appellant’s fall is not readily ascertainable from the record. In any event, Jarrells subsequently pulled around Maxwell’s vehicle and ran over appellant’s left arm as she lay on the pavement.

As a result of this incident, Jarrells was charged with two counts of felonious assault in violation of R.C. 2903.11. Following plea negotiations, he agreed to plead guilty to one of the two counts contained in the indictment.

Primarily relying on Jarrells’ felonious assault conviction, the trial court summarily ruled in favor of appellee Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company on its declaratory judgment action.

Pursuant to an intentional injury exclusionary clause in Nationwide’s insurance policy, the trial court determined that Nationwide had no duty to defend or indemnify Jarrells. Subsequent to the trial court’s decision, the appellant brought this appeal.

Appellant’s first and second assignments of error are interrelated and will be discussed together. They provide:

“I. The trial court erred in granting declaratory judgment to appellee because there was no showing that the intentionally caused injury exclusion of appellee’s insurance policy was applicable to the facts of this case.

“II.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.