Ohio Court of Appeals August 19, 1991, No. 1-90-114. (Newland v. Amin)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-08-1991

Thomas F. Bryant, Presiding Judge.

This is an appeal from a decision entered in the Common Pleas Court of Allen County, granting summary judgment in favor of the defendant-appellee, Robert I. Curry, M.D. and dismissing plaintiff’s complaint against him.

In December 1987, because seven-year-old Shawn Newland was overweight, the Newlands’ family physician, Robert I. Curry, M.D., tested him for suspected diabetes. Dr. Curry performed a chemical strip test in his office to determine Shawn’s blood sugar. The result of this test indicated a normal blood sugar level. Still suspecting diabetes, Dr. Curry ordered a five-hour glucose tolerance test (“GTT”). The result of that test was also normal.

On October 18, 1988, Shawn, then eight years old, was taken by his mother to see Dr. Curry. He was complaining of stomach pain, vomiting, headaches and nocturia, and had been experiencing these symptoms four to five days prior to this visit. It is apparently undisputed that Dr. Curry at this time considered the likelihood of Shawn’s having diabetes and referred to the GTT done in December 1987, but, noting that that test had been normal, considered it to still be valid. Dr. Curry ordered some blood work, but did not order a new chemical strip or GTT. The blood work ordered was not for the purpose of determining whether Shawn had diabetes.

*618

On Monday, October 24, 1988, Shawn’s condition had worsened and he returned to Dr. Curry. Between the October 18 visit and the October 24 visit, Shawn had lost approximately seven and one-half pounds. He had symptoms of tongue dehydration and had been vomiting frequently over the weekend. Dr. Curry hospitalized Shawn at Lima Memorial Hospital that afternoon.

During the course of blood work done routinely on all patients admitted to the hospital, it was determined that Shawn had diabetes. These tests further revealed that his diabetes had progressed to diabetic ketoacidosis. The nursing personnel contacted Dr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.