Circuit Court for the Judicial Circuits of Florida June 13, 1991, Case No. 89-0032-CA-AP-LpD (Lower Court Case No. 61293/4RW (State v. Davis)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-06-1991
OPINION OF THE COURT
BRIESE, Judge.
THIS COURT reviews the trial court’s December 6, 1989 Order (R 20) granting Appellee’s Motion to Suppress (R 16-18) based on the *20State’s alleged failure to substantially comply with HRS Rule 10D-42.024(l)(f) requiring a twenty minute observation period prior to the administration of a breath test. The only evidence of the suppression hearing was the testimony of the breath test/video operator and the maintenance technician. (See R 27-61, 62-87, respectively) and one composite exhibit consisting of an operational checklist and the instrument printer card (R 19).
Ormond Beach Police Officer, Jim Harvin, the breath test/video operator, testified that he first observed the Appellant 2:21 a.m. (R 33, 34, 36). The first breath test occurred at 2:47 a.m. with results of .181 percent; the second test occurred at 2:48 a.m. with results of .186 percent (R 30-31, 33, 43). The only exhibit in evidence, the instrument printer card confirms the above listed times (R 19). Officer Harvin was sure of the times involved since his wristwatch, a wall clock, and the intoxilyzer all had the same times (R 34, 37, 43-44, 52). Officer Harvin couldn’t recall the time the video taping began or ended (R 35, 50, 60).
Defense Counsel, on cross-examination, asked two “if’ (speculation) questions regarding time conflicts between the video operation and breath test operation; to which the officer answered (R 44). The Assistant State Attorney also asked about the discrepancy (R 37). The response was that the officer [who evidently completed the video processing form] apparently had the wrong time (R 37, See also R 50). The officer [Secord] who completed the video processing form was not called to testify. Likewise a video processing form was not admitted into evidence (R 50).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit