New York Supreme Court February 15, 1991 (Winter v. Bernstein)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-02-1991
OPINION OF THE COURT
Edward H. Lehner, J.
The principal question raised on the motions before the court is whether the terms of a will of a person who died owning all of a corporation’s shares can control the corporation’s current dividend policy.
The individual defendants move pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (7) to dismiss the complaint or, in the alternative, for summary judgment. Plaintiffs cross-move for partial summary judgment on their third and fourth causes of action.
The crux of this interfamily dispute is over the management of National Reprographics, Inc. (Reprographies), a subchapter S corporation which has 110 shares outstanding. Plaintiffs Lily B. Sheflan and Marcella Burnell have life estates in the income from 20 and 10 shares respectively pursuant to the will of Edwin J. Bernstein (the Will). Mr. Bernstein died in 1962 owning all of the shares of the corporation. Defendant *1019Madeline Bernstein, a daughter-in-law of the testator, is the controlling shareholder, chairperson of the board of directors (the Board), and secretary and treasurer of the corporation. Solomon Magid, Madeline Bernstein’s son-in-law, is president and a member of the Board, and her daughter Nan Magid is also a Board member. The persons who possess the remainder interest in the shares of Sheflan and Burnell are Madeline Bernstein’s grandchildren.
In 1964 the directors and shareholders agreed that the previous policy of distributing 100% of corporate profits to shareholders was adversely affecting the company’s ability to grow, and thereafter the Board declared dividends that averaged approximately 60% of earnings.
The complaint asserts that while distribution of the percentage of profits as dividends declined, distribution to corporate executives in the form of salaries increased disproportionately.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit