Court of Appeals of North Carolina December 17, 1991, No. 9119SC16 (In re the Paper Writing of Vestal)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-12-1991

EAGLES, Judge.

I

During oral argument appellant contended that Judge Walker did not have subject matter jurisdiction to enter his order because it was signed out of session. We disagree.

In State v. Horner, 310 N.C. 274, 278, 311 S.E.2d 281, 285 (1984), the defendant claimed that a trial court’s order was null ,and void because it had been entered out of session and out of *742district without his consent. There, the Supreme Court noted that “it appears from the transcript that the trial judge ruled on each of the objects of the motion ... at the time of the trial. He later reduced his ruling to writing, signed the order, and filed it with the clerk.” Id. at 279, 311 S.E.2d at 285. The Court “held that the trial court’s order . . . was not improperly entered ‘out of session and out of district’ where the court passed on each part of the motion ... in open court as it was argued and later reduced its ruling to writing, signed the order, and filed it with the clerk.” State v. Smith, 320 N.C. 404, 415-416, 358 S.E.2d 329, 335 (1987).

Here, Judge Walker heard the propounder’s motion on 5 October 1990. After hearing counsel’s arguments Judge Walker made his decision on the motion in open court. That same day he prepared a handwritten memorandum outlining his findings of fact and his decision to dismiss the caveat. That handwritten memorandum, which appears in the record before us, also indicates that the “[attorney for [the] propounder was directed to incorporate [the] findings into a formal order for later signature.” On 2 November 1990 Judge Walker signed the order submitted by the propounder. The order was filed with the clerk of court on 2 November 1990. Accordingly, we conclude that entry of the order was not improper.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.