Court of Appeals of Oregon February 12, 1992, WCB 88-01147; CA A62442 (Westfall v. Rust International)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-02-1992

*291

WARREN, P. J.

This case is before us on remand from the Supreme Court. 312 Or 34, 815 P2d 1272 (1991). The court vacated our award of sanctions made pursuant to ORS 656.390 and remanded for further consideration in light of its opinion in

Mattiza v. Foster,

311 Or 1, 803 P2d 723 (1990).

In

Mattiza,

the court considered sanctions under ORS 20.105(1), which provides:

“In any civil action, suit or other proceeding in a district court, a circuit court or the Oregon Tax Court, or in any civil appeal to or review by the Court of Appeals or Supreme Court, the court may, in its discretion, award reasonable attorney fees appropriate in the circumstances to a party against whom a claim, defense or ground for appeal or review is asserted, if that party is a prevailing party in the proceeding and to be paid by the party asserting the claim, defense or ground, upon a finding by the court that the party willfully disobeyed a court order or acted in bad faith, wantonly or solely for oppressive reasons.”

One of the issues was whether, when the claim is that the party acted in bad faith, sanctions can be awarded without a finding that the claim or defense was meritless. The court reviewed the legislative history, which indicated that the legislature intended to incorporate the federal bad faith standard referred to in

Alyeska Pipeline Co. v. Wilderness Society,

421 US 240, 95 S Ct 1612, 44 L Ed 2d 141 (1975), under which a court has inherent equitable power to award attorney fees when an unsuccessful litigant has acted in bad faith. Following the federal interpretation of that rule, the court concluded that a finding of meritlessness was a necessary precursor to an award of sanctions for bad faith under ORS 20.105(1). 311 Or at 8.

The court did not offer any guidance as to its reason for vacating our award of sanctions in this case, and it is not readily apparent whether or how we are to apply

Mattiza’s

interpretation of ORS 20.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.