West Virginia Supreme Court October 22, 1992, 21110 (At & T Communications of West Virginia, Inc. v. Public Service Commission)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-10-1992

NEELY, Justice:

We are faced with a dispute between telephone companies who do business in West Virginia and the Public Service Commission (PSC). The PSC requires all utilities doing business in the State to file annual reports; the companies are willing to

*252

file annual reports so long as their competitors do not have access to the information contained within the reports. AT & T Communications of West Virginia, Inc. (AT & T) petitioned the PSC for a protective order covering

all information

in its annual report. We believe AT & T must be more specific in its request, and therefore remand the case to the Public Service Commission for further proceedings.

It seems that the real issue in this case is not the status of the law surrounding privilege, but something much more fundamental: the role of the Public Service Commission in regulating competitive industries. AT & T, U.S. Sprint, and MCI contend that they are in a competitive industry; thus there is no need for a regulatory body to oversee the industry and impose rules that do nothing but hinder competition. The PSC agreed with this position when it “streamlined” its regulation of the long-distance industry.

1

Under the Legislature’s grant of authority to the Public Service Commission in

W. Va. Code

24-2-9 [1991],

2

the PSC may compel all organizations subject to its regulation to prepare such reports as the PSC demands. Furthermore, the PSC is required to preserve these reports and to publish an annual statistical tabulation of the information provided. The PSC is not required to print every word of the reports, but the PSC has the authority to print every word if it so desires.

The PSC applies the same standards that the courts apply in determining what information should be covered by protective orders.

Appalachian Power Co.,

38 P.U.R. 4th 73 (1980);

C & P Telephone Co.,

68 P.U.R. 4th 163 (1985). That standard is embodied in Rule 26(c),

WVRCP:

(c)

Protective orders.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.