Supreme Court of Louisiana May 26, 1992, 88-KH-2816 (State Ex Rel. Mims v. Butler)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-05-1992
601 So.2d 649 (1992) STATE of Louisiana ex rel. Ira Joe MIMS v. Hilton BUTLER, Warden, Louisiana State Penitentiary. No. 88-KH-2816. Supreme Court of Louisiana. May 26, 1992. Elizabeth Cole and Terry E. Allbritton, Tulane Law Clinic, New Orleans, for plaintiff-applicant. Richard Phillip Ieyoub, Atty. Gen., Paul J. Carmouche, Dist. Atty., and Catherine Estopinal, Asst. Dist. Atty., for defendant-respondent. Lennie Francis Perez and Alton Tracy Moran, Baton Rouge, for Public Def. Off. 19th Judicial Dist. Court, amicus curiae. Helen G. Berrigan, New Orleans, for Indigent Def. Bd. 24th Judicial Dist. Court, amicus curiae. G. Paul Marx, Lafayette, for Public Def. Prog. 15th Judicial Dist. Court, amicus curiae. John Michael Crochet and John Francis LaVern, Lake Charles, for Public Def. Prog. 14th Judicial Dist. Court and Public Def. Prog. 38th Judicial Dist. Court, amicus curiae. Ellis Paul Adams, Jr., for Louisiana Dist. Attorney's Assn., amicus curiae. *650 Robert Stephen Glass, New Orleans, for LA Assn. Crim. Def. Lawyer, amicus curiae. No Atty. Listed for Orleans Indigent Def. Bd., amicus curiae. ON REHEARING CALOGERO, Chief Justice.[*] We granted certiorari to determine whether Act 688 of 1982, amending Louisiana's Habitual Offender Law, La.R.S. 15:529.1, legislatively repudiated nineteen years of jurisprudence which has consistently held that second offender status can only result from an offense committed after a first conviction, and third offender status can only result from an offense committed after a conviction which qualifies a defendant as a second offender. In our original opinion in this case, we held that the 1982 amendment legislatively overruled the Jackson[1] sequential requirement rule and that Mims' application for post conviction relief was properly denied by the court of appeal. We granted a rehearing on relator's application. After further study, we find that R.S. 15:529.1 as amended by Act 688 of 1982 is vague and ambiguous.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit