District Court, W.D. Virginia July 28, 1992, Civ. A. 91-0040-L (F.P. Corp. v. Golden West Foods, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-07-1992
MEMORANDUM OPINION
KISER, District Judge.
This is an action by a motor carrier, F.P. Corp. (“FP”), against a shipper, Golden West Foods, Inc. (“Golden West”), to recover the difference between FP’s tariff rate and a negotiated rate between the parties, commonly known as an undercharge action. Golden West has moved to stay this case and refer it to the Interstate Commerce Commission (“ICC”). Because this case does not involve issues requiring the ICC’s expertise, I will deny the motion. Regarding the merits, as I find that FP did not have a valid tariff on file at the time it made shipments for Golden West, I will grant Golden West’s motion for summary judgment and deny FP’s motion for summary judgment.
The Motion to Stay and Refer to the ICC
Golden West contends that this case raises two issues that are within the special competence of the ICC and should be referred to it under the doctrine of primary jurisdiction: the determination if a carrier conducted business as a contract or common carrier, and the determination if a tariff was duly filed and adopted by the carrier relying upon it.
The Fourth Circuit has stated that if the question is solely one of law, a district court does not need to refer matters to the ICC.
Montgomery Ward and Co. v. Roy Stone Transfer Corp.,
329 F.2d 172, 174 (4th Cir.1964) (citing
Great Northern Ry. Co. v. Merchants Elevator Co.,
259 U.S. 285, 42 S.Ct. 477, 66 L.Ed. 943 (1922)). Several courts have recently addressed the issue of contract or common carriage without referral to the ICC.
See, e.g., Covey v. ConAgra, Inc.,
788 F.Supp. 1160 (D.Colo.1992);
Dan Barclay, Inc. v. Stewart & Stevenson Servs., Inc.,
761 F.Supp. 194 (D.Mass.1991). I see no need to deviate from this course.
The determination of whether or not a tariff was duly filed and adopted is also a question of law which does not require referral to the ICC.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit