Court of Appeals of Maryland March 12, 1992, 42 September Term, 1991 (Batson v. Shiflett)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-03-1992

*692

KARWACKI, Judge.

In

Batson v. Shiflett,

86 Md.App. 340, 586 A.2d 792 (1991), the Court of Special Appeals affirmed a judgment entered on a jury verdict in the Circuit Court for Baltimore County awarding compensatory and punitive damages against petitioners, Industrial Union of Marine and Shipbuilding Workers of America, IAM, District Lodge 4 (National Union) and Arthur E. Batson, Jr., its President, in favor of respondent, A. Spencer Shiflett, Jr., former President of Local 33, an affiliate of the National Union. The jury credited Shiflett’s allegations that he was defamed in leaflets disseminated and speeches made by Batson and subjected to intentional infliction of emotional distress by the National Union and Batson in the course of a heated labor dispute. We granted certiorari to consider the following issues:

—whether the decision below violated principles of issue preclusion and of federal labor law preemption.

—whether the evidence demonstrated that the allegedly defamatory statements at issue were substantially true, or, even if they were not, whether there was clear and convincing evidence that the statements were made with actual (constitutional) malice.

—whether the jury was properly instructed as to the element of malice in the defamation action.

—whether the holding that petitioners’ conduct was sufficiently “extreme and outrageous” to permit recovery for intentional infliction of emotional distress conflicts with Maryland law, federal labor law, or the First Amendment.

I.

Shiflett began his employment at the Sparrows Point shipyard of the Bethlehem Steel Corporation, (Bethlehem) in 1967, and shortly thereafter became a member of Local 33. After serving in a variety of local union offices, Shiflett was elected President of Local 33 in 1980, and was re-elected in

*693

1983. The facts underlying this appeal stem from a dispute that arose in 1984, while Shiflett was president of Local 33.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.