Court of Appeals of Wisconsin February 26, 1992, 91-1556 (Paytes v. Kost)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-02-1992
BROWN, J.
Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company appeals a discovery sanction assigning Nationwide primary coverage for all lawsuits arising from an auto accident. Because the statute permitting discovery sanctions limits such sanctions to the case at hand, we conclude that a discovery sanction cannot extend to liability for damages in a case subsequently consolidated with the case in which the sanction was ordered.
Ceonia Paytes and Jeanette McMillian brought separate lawsuits to recover damages they sustained when a truck driven by Gerald Kost struck the car driven by Paytes. Paytes's lawsuit was commenced prior to McMillian's. Kost's insurer was National Surety Corporation, which filed a third-party complaint in Paytes's case against Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company. Nationwide insured Bulk Commodities Transport, Inc., which leased the truck driven by Kost. National Surety sought a declaratory judgment as to which company provided primary insurance coverage.
Prior to consolidation of
Paytes
with
McMillian,
Judge Stephen A. Simanek issued a discovery sanction against Nationwide in
Paytes.
The sanction assigned Nationwide primary coverage for any damages arising from the
accident
because of Nationwide's repeated failure to comply with the statutory and court-ordered deadlines for discovery requested by National Surety. Nationwide failed to produce the complete insurance policy covering its client, Bulk Commodities. The trial court characterized the documents Nationwide did pro
*393
duce after several discovery requests as a "real hodgepodge."
After Judge Emmanuel Vuvunas consolidated
Paytes
and
McMillian,
he adopted Judge Simanek's order as applicable to the consolidated case. However, Judge Vuvunas indicated that he was simply reiterating the earlier order and was not issuing a new order in the consolidated case.
The consolidated case was tried before Judge Dennis Barry with Nationwide defending Kost. The jury awarded damages of $6750 to Paytes, $238,536.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit