Texas Court of Appeals, 1st District (Houston) March 12, 1992, 01-90-00401-CR (Coots v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-03-1992

OPINION

COHEN, Justice.

A jury found appellant guilty of aggravated robbery. After considering appellant’s plea of true to two enhancements for aggravated assault and forgery, the jury assessed punishment at 70 years confinement. We reverse and remand.

Appellant contends the evidence was insufficient, the trial court erred in allowing the bailiff to testify after the rule had been invoked, and the trial court erred in admitting hearsay evidence that appellant had used a telephone number which the robber gave the victim the day before the robbery. We hold the evidence was sufficient, but harmful error occurred when the hearsay was admitted and when the bailiff testified. The bailiff’s performance in this case raises serious concerns, as discussed below.

Although the evidence is plainly sufficient based on the victim’s testimony

*957

alone, we state it in detail because of its importance in ruling on the evidence points.

During the afternoon of September 12, 1989, Debra Charbonneau was approached outside her suburban Houston home by appellant and another unidentified man. They inquired about the possibility of doing yard work. Ms. Charbonneau produced a piece of paper, upon which appellant wrote “Turner Yard Work” and a telephone number to call if she wished to employ them. They talked about 10 minutes, during which Ms. Charbonneau observed appellant at distances as close as three feet.

About 3:00 p.m. the next day, appellant returned to the Charbonneau home. When Ms. Charbonneau answered the door, he drew a gun and forced his way into the house. Ms. Charbonneau surrendered her jewelry and her purse, and she was bound and gagged. She clearly saw her assailant at close range and undisguised during the robbery.

Ms. Charbonneau summoned Harris County constables immediately after the robbery. She described the robber as being about five feet, seven or eight inches tall, slender, weighing about 140 pounds, and having crowded front teeth.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.