Ohio Court of Appeals March 10, 1992, No. 91AP-907. (Columbus Division of Income Tax v. Boles)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-03-1992

Petree, Judge.

This is an appeal from the Franklin County Municipal Court, which granted judgment to E. Thomas Boles, Jr., M.D., defendant herein. The city of Columbus, Division of Income Tax, plaintiff herein, appeals and asserts the following assignments of error:

“I. The trial court committed prejudicial error in determining that income from defendant’s interest in the Atlas Building was not taxable by the City of Columbus.

*619

“II. The trial court committed prejudicial error by entering judgment for defendant and against plaintiff on plaintiffs complaint and by entering judgment against plaintiff and for defendant on defendant’s counterclaim.”

These two assignments of error present a single question for our review. That question is whether Columbus may tax a nonresident for limited partnership income derived from partnership business operations conducted within city limits.

Plaintiff filed a complaint on May 17,1990 in the Franklin County Municipal Court against defendant, alleging that he failed to pay sufficient municipal income tax for the years 1986 and 1987. Plaintiff demanded judgment in the amount of $1,565.92 plus interest. Defendant answered and defended, arguing that plaintiff had no authority to tax his limited partnership income. He also counterclaimed for a refund of certain taxes previously paid for such income.

The parties submitted stipulations and the cause was tried to the court. The stipulations state that defendant is a resident of Upper Arlington, Ohio. During the years 1986 and 1987, defendant was a limited partner in several business ventures, including Atlas Building, Ltd. The principal office and location of operations of this limited partnership is in Columbus. In 1986, defendant derived $32,856 in income from his interest in Atlas Building, Ltd. In 1987, he derived $84,026 in income from it.

Given these elementary facts, the trial court held that plaintiff could not tax defendant’s limited partnership income.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.