Missouri Court of Appeals January 28, 1992, No. 60288 (Overland Outdoor Advertising Co. v. State ex rel. Missouri Highway & Transportation Commission)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-01-1992
CRANE, Judge.
Defendant Missouri Highway and Transportation Commission [Commission] appeals from the order of the circuit court setting aside its decisions relating to removal of advertising billboards on the grounds that photocopies of exhibits in the court file were illegible, and thus the agency decision was not supported by competent and substantial evidence. We reverse the judgment of the circuit court and remand.
In 1979 the Commission notified Overland Outdoor Advertising Company [Overland] that it must remove two billboards which the Commission alleged were erected between January 1, 1968 and March 20, 1972 in violation of the Missouri Highway Beautification Act, § 226.500 et seq. RSMo 1978. Overland requested hearings to contest the notices. The hearing examiner conducted hearings in 1985, during which applications for a permit to maintain outdoor advertising for both billboards were admitted into evidence. The Commission, upon a request for administrative review, concluded that the billboards were not lawfully existing signs and were subject to removal without compensation.
Overland filed a petition for review in the Circuit Court of Franklin County pursuant to § 536.110 RSMo 1986. The Commission, at the request of Overland, prepared and filed in the circuit court the record before the agency as required by § 536.130 RSMo 1986. The record included the hearing transcript and exhibits. Instead of the originals, however, photocopies of the applications for permits to maintain outdoor advertising for both signs were filed with the circuit court. In its judgment the court found the photocopies of the applications to be illegible and therefore that the findings of the Commission were not supported by competent and substantial evidence. The court set aside the Commission’s decisions. The Commission filed a Motion to Set Aside Judgment and Request for Reconsideration of the Evidence along with the original applications which were legible.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit