Court of Appeals of Tennessee December 30, 1992 (Beer House Distributors, Inc. v. Huddleston)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-12-1992

OPINION

CANTRELL, Judge.

This action involves the confiscation of 190 cases of beer and of a delivery truck belonging to the appellant, a wholesale beer distributor, by the Tennessee Department of Revenue. The chancellor upheld the decision of the commissioner of revenue approving the confiscation. We affirm.

I.

The appellant, a Tennessee corporation owned by Mary Kinney, operates as a beer wholesaler out of Clarksville, Tennessee. The appellant also has a distributorship in Kentucky. On January 31,1991, one of the appellant’s employees was making deliveries of pre-sold beer to the appellant’s Kentucky customers. Due to confusion as to the amount of beer to be delivered to each of the Kentucky customers, not all of the beer was delivered. The employee drove to the appellant’s warehouse in Clarksville and parked the truck containing the undelivered beer. Included on the truck were brands of beer which the appellant was not authorized to distribute in Tennessee. Upon being informed that the beer had not been delivered in Kentucky, and knowing that the beer was not supposed to be in Tennessee, Ms. Kinney planned to drive the beer back to Kentucky the next day.

However, on the morning of February 1, 1991, agents of the Tennessee Department of Revenue went to the appellant’s warehouse in Clarksville to enforce a jeopardy assessment for delinquent taxes. No representatives of the appellant were present and the warehouse, a tobacco barn, was unlocked. The agents discovered the beer truck, which was locked, and called a locksmith to open the truck bays. Upon inspecting the bays of the truck, the agents discovered the illegal beer. Accordingly, the beer truck and its contents were seized as contraband.

The appellant requested a hearing with the commissioner regarding the confiscated property. The administrative law judge held that the beer and the truck were contraband pursuant to Tenn.Code Ann. § 57-5-409 and subject to seizure and disposal.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.