Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit March 30, 1992, 91-15049 (Paradise Land and Cattle Company, a Co-Partnership v. McWilliams Enterprises, Inc., a California Corporation)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-03-1992

GOODWIN, Circuit Judge:

The seller of a Nevada ranch, Paradise Land & Cattle Co. (“Paradise”), sued to enforce a guaranty made by one of the buyers, McWilliams Enterprises, Inc. (“Enterprises”). The district court granted summary judgment in favor of Paradise.

*1465

Enterprises appeals, contending that it was entitled to California’s statutory protection from deficiency judgments on purchase-money obligations secured by real property. We affirm.

In the 1970s, Herb McWilliams and his son Don were California cattle ranchers. The McWilliamses conducted their ranching operations through two corporations, Enterprises and McWilliams Land & Cattle Co., Inc. (“Land & Cattle”). Enterprises’ only shareholders were Herb (55%) and a trust in part for the benefit of Don (45%). During the same period, Paradise was the owner of a Nevada ranch. In the early 1980s, the McWilliamses decided to buy the Paradise ranch.

In late 1981, the parties signed an option contract. Under the contract, Enterprises and Land & Cattle acquired an option to purchase the Paradise ranch for $2,600,000. Part of the purchase price was to be in the form of a note signed by Enterprises and Land & Cattle in favor of Paradise, secured by a deed of trust in the ranch. Pursuant to the 1981 agreement, Enterprises and Land & Cattle took possession of the ranch and began conducting operations.

In early 1982, Enterprises and Land & Cattle exercised their option. While the deal was in escrow, the McWilliamses decided to seek a modification of the transaction which would provide Herb with tax benefits. Under their proposal, the type and amount of consideration would remain the same, but Herb and Don as individuals would become parties to the transaction. Instead of Enterprises and Land & Cattle, Herb and Don individually would sign the purchase money note in favor of Paradise secured by the ranch. Enterprises would still contribute land and cash.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.