Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit June 10, 1992, 973, Docket 91-1560 (United States v. Thomas H. Gannon, Jr.)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-06-1992

OAKES, Chief Judge:

This appeal involves a question under the Double Jeopardy Clause. The government seeks to prosecute the appellant, Thomas H. Gannon, Jr., for perjury in denying certain bid-rigging allegations before a grand jury to which he was summoned after he and his company were acquitted by a jury in a previous bid-rigging conspiracy indictment. In the previous indictment, it was alleged that he and other road paving contractors conspired to rig bids to obtain slurry seal road paving work awarded by the Village of Pelham Manor, New York, and the Town of Brookhaven, New York. It alleged that Gannon and his company had agreed with the other contractors to submit “accommodation bids” that would facilitate one other contractor (Lansdell) in obtaining work let by the Village of Pelham Manor,

*41

and that in return Gannon would win the work of the Town of Brookhaven through similar accommodation bids by the other contractors. At trial, the prosecution sought to prove that Gannon and the other contractors were trying to keep Lansdell out of Suffolk County. In the course of the trial, evidence was introduced to the effect that the contractors, including Gan-non, divided up the six maintenance districts of Suffolk County. This evidence was objected to by Gannon but it was admitted as evidence of a larger conspiracy and to show Gannon’s knowledge and intent. Admitted into evidence was a government-compiled summary of bids submitted to Suffolk County for slurry seal work let by the Suffolk County Department of Highways.

Following the verdict of acquittal in reference to the Brookhaven-Pelham Manor conspiracy, Gannon was summoned before a grand jury and asked questions relative to Suffolk County highway bid rigging. His denial of having had conversations or attending meetings regarding that bid rigging led to the instant penury indictment.

In this interlocutory appeal from denial of a motion to dismiss the perjury indictment,

see Abney v. United States,

431 U.S.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.