Court of Appeals for the First Circuit August 31, 1992, 91-2184 (Bart Zebrowski v. Michael H. Hanna, Salvatore Altomare)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-08-1992

BREYER, Chief Judge.

The legal issue before us concerns the scope of the district court’s “inherent power” to “fashion an appropriate sanction for conduct which abuses the judicial process.”

Chambers v. Nasco, Inc.,

— U.S. -, -, 111 S.Ct. 2123, 2133, 115 L.Ed.2d 27 (1991). The four appellants are plaintiffs in a lawsuit against a developer who had sold them, and retained mortgages on, condominiums, and who counterclaimed for second-mortgage payments. The plaintiffs told the district court they were providing

*1002

the defendant with some financial security, in case they lost, by making their mortgage payments into a kind of escrow account. They failed to make the payments, and the district court dismissed their claims. They argue on appeal that the court lacked the legal power to impose this type of “sanction.” Given the circumstances here present, however, we conclude that the district court acted lawfully, and we affirm its judgment.

I

The Key Events

We shall first set forth, in chronological order and in somewhat simplified form, the significant events that the record reveals.

1.

1985-86.

The four appellants, and twenty-four other initial plaintiffs in this case, bought Cape Cod condominiums from defendant Michael Hanna and the Soundings Seaside Realty Trust (collectively “Hanna”). They borrowed most of the money for the purchases, and Hanna held second mortgages on the properties.

2.

December 1988.

The twenty-eight plaintiffs sued Hanna, claiming that he had misled them in ways that violated federal securities laws, federal anti-racketeering laws, and various state tort and contract laws.

3.

February 1989.

Hanna, stating that the plaintiffs had stopped making monthly payments on their second mortgages, counterclaimed for the money due.

4.

Summer 1989.

The plaintiffs rented their condominiums to various vacationers.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.