Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit September 18, 1992, 91-5972 (Barry A. Kozyra, Arbitrator, Geraldine Della Buono v. Paul J. Allen M & G Convoy, Third-Party v. Angelo Soldani, Third-Party)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-09-1992
combined-opinion
973 F.2d 1110 Barry A. KOZYRA, Arbitrator, Geraldine Della Buono, Appellant, v. Paul J. ALLEN; M & G Convoy, Third-Party Plaintiffs, v. Angelo SOLDANI, Third-Party Defendant. No. 91-5972. United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit. Argued July 10, 1992. Decided Aug. 26, 1992. Order Denying Rehearing Sept. 18, 1992. Robert V. Falvey (argued), Michael Sussen, Pennsauken, N.J., for appellant. Michael F. Nestor (argued), Anthony J. Iacullo, Tompkins, McGuire & Wachenfeld, Newark, N.J., for appellees, Paul J. Allen and M & G Convoy. Before SLOVITER, Chief Judge, STAPLETON and ROSENN, Circuit Judges. OPINION OF THE COURT ROSENN, Circuit Judge. 1 In this diversity action, we are asked to predict whether the New Jersey Supreme Court would carve out an exception to its "entire controversy doctrine" in favor of the appellant on this appeal. Plaintiff-appellant Della Buono, the defendant in an earlier action, argues that she did not have a fair opportunity to present her claim for personal injuries because her insurance carrier did not correspond with her, she did not participate fully in the first litigation, and she was not made aware of her obligation to assert her personal injury claim. The district court in this proceeding granted the defendants' motion to dismiss Della Buono's claims with prejudice pursuant to New Jersey's entire controversy doctrine which precludes claims that are not joined in the underlying controversy. Della Buono appealed to this court. We affirm.I. 2 This litigation arose out of a three vehicle accident which occurred on May 17, 1988 in Newark, New Jersey. Plaintiff Della Buono was traveling in the left lane of the New Jersey Turnpike when Paul J. Allen, who was operating a tractor trailer owned by M & G Convoy, rear-ended the vehicle driven by Angelo Soldani and caused it to spin out of control and directly into Della Buono's path. Della Buono sustained injury to her knee requiring arthroscopic surgery.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit