Civil Court of the City of New York April 9, 1992 (Pereira v. Phillips)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-04-1992

*156OPINION OF THE COURT

Ronni D. Birnbaum, J.

Petitioner moves to strike respondent’s counterclaims and to preclude for failure to provide a bill of particulars. Respondent opposes the motion.

Petitioner is a Trustee in Bankruptcy appointed pursuant to the order of the Honorable Burton R. Lifland, Bankruptcy Judge, Southern District, New York. In or about the month of October 1991, petitioner commenced the instant proceeding against respondent to recover rent allegedly unpaid since September 1991, for apartment No. 47 located at 274 West 140 Street, New York City, New York (the premises). Respondent served her answer in late October raising various affirmative defenses and interposing certain counterclaims. The latter included claims for: rent overcharge, malicious prosecution, breach of warranty of habitability, retaliatory eviction and attorney’s fees.

Petitioner now moves to strike respondent’s counterclaims arguing suit against a Trustee in Bankruptcy is prohibited by State and Federal law. Specifically, petitioner contends CPLR 3019 (c) expressly prohibits suit against a Trustee; further, that regardless of State law, permission to bring suit must be obtained from the Bankruptcy Court which appointed petitioner before commencement of such action.

Suits commenced by a Trustee fall into two categories. First, those actions which are brought as successor to the debtor’s interest included in the estate pursuant to 11 USC § 541. Second, those which are brought under one or more of the Trustee’s avoiding powers. This proceeding clearly involves the former.

CPLR 3019 (c) permits a counterclaim against a Trustee or nominal plaintiff, to the extent of the plaintiff’s claim, providing that cause of action might have been interposed in an action brought by the person beneficially interested. (Helman v Dixon, 71 Misc 2d 1057 [Civ Ct, Queens County 1972].)

Here, petitioner seeks to recover alleged unpaid rent.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.