New York Supreme Court July 15, 1992 (People v. Maniscalco)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-07-1992

OPINION OF THE COURT

Charles A. Kuffner, Jr., J.

Defendant is charged with criminal possession of a weapon *892in the third degree. After conducting a hearing on July 2, 1992, defendant moved to dismiss or, in the alternative, reduce the indictment to a misdemeanor possession because the circumstances concerning the weapon’s location fall within the exception of section 265.02 (4) of the Penal Law.

The provisions of this section make it a class D felony to possess a loaded firearm unless "such possession takes place in such person’s home or place of business” in which event the violation would only rise to the level of a class A misdemeanor. The loaded .22 caliber automatic Raven revolver was found in the glove compartment of defendant’s car after a permissible search. The vehicle was parked on the driveway of defendant’s residential property. At issue in this case is whether the revolver was found in defendant’s home or place of business.

While the exception in the statute acknowledges the right to defend one’s self or property, it does not create blanket authority to possess unlicensed firearms. "As the court stated in [People v] Rondon ([109 Misc 2d 394,] 397): The very strictness of the New York provision * * * appears to be part of a continuing trend * * * to impose severe restrictions on the possession of firearms. [T]he Governor of New York State [has] stated * * * that "[w]e must let it be known that New York has the toughest gun law in the country and that it will be strictly enforced”.’ ” (People v Abbatiello, 129 Misc 2d 831, 832.) Possession of loaded firearms to protect persons or property in their homes or places of business is less reprehensible than possession for other purposes. (People v Powell, 54 NY2d 524, 526.) The statute codifies strong and competing public policy considerations, regarding bearing of arms.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.