Civil Court of the City of New York September 2, 1992 (Woodbury Automotive Warehouse, Inc. v. Island Speed Auto Supplies, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-09-1992

OPINION OF THE COURT

Thomas P. Aliotta, J.

This is an action to recover a secured interest worth $12,231.82 from defendant Motor Age Inc. (hereinafter referred to as Motor Age) which allegedly converted defendant Island Speed Auto Supplies, Inc.’s inventory in which plaintiff claims it holds a primary security interest. Defendant Motor Age moves to dismiss the sixth and only cause of action against it upon the ground that the court lacks in personam jurisdiction. In the alternative, defendant moves to vacate the notice of trial filed by plaintiff and strike the action from the Trial Calendar, upon the grounds that plaintiff has not complied with a demand for a bill of particulars and Motor Age has not had an adequate opportunity to conduct discovery. Plaintiff has filed opposing papers.

CCA 404 (a) permits the court to exercise personal jurisdiction over any nonresident of the City of New York if a cause of action arises from any of the enumerated acts listed in the section. Pursuant to CCA 404 (d) a corporation shall be deemed a nonresident of the City of New York if service of the summons cannot be effected by personal delivery within the City limits so as to acquire in personam jurisdiction. If CCA 404 (d) is satisfied, then under CCA 404 (a) personal jurisdiction over the nonresident may be exercised in the same manner as if he or she were a domiciliary of the State and a resident of the City of New York.

*383The affidavit of Marion Romano, vice-president for office operations of Motor Age indicates that, "[a]t the time the summons in this action was sent to the Secretary of State, Motor Age maintained no office or place of business within the City of New York”. Her statement demonstrates that plaintiff could not effect personal delivery within the City limits and therefore Motor Age is deemed a nonresident of the City pursuant to CCA 404 (d).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.