Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Lehigh County July 8, 1992, no. 1464 (Rothermel v. Owen Illinois Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-07-1992
KLEIN, J.,
Leland E. Rothermel developed asbestosis and lung cancer and died of a heart attack on October 7, 1988. The defense conceded that asbestos exposure was a substantial contributing factor to his lung cancer. Plaintiff’s expert physician opined that the lung cancer was a substantial contributing factor to Mr. Rothermel’s fatal heart attack.
The non-settling defendants raise three arguments in their post-verdict motions:
(1) They complain that the court erred in failing to reduce the verdict to 49 percent of what the jury found, since the court did allow the jury to make an apportionment of causation between cigarette smoking and asbestos exposure on a special interrogatory. The court took the *21position that: (a) cancer is a single disease and there was not sufficient medical testimony to support an allocation; and (b) even if an allocation was to be made, the cigarette companies were not joined, there was no evidence of contributory negligence, and the asbestos defendants are liable for the full verdict under these circumstances. If they wish, they can file a contribution action against the cigarette manufacturers after they pay the verdict.
(2) The defendants differ as to whether each defendant should pay an equal share or the respective liability should be based on the jury’s allocation among defendants. The jury allocation was based on Mr. Rothermel’s testimony regarding differing exposure to the various products. The court initially held that under Walton v. Avco Corp., 383 Pa. Super. 518, 544-47, 557 A.2d 372, 386-87 (1989), Pennsylvania law requires an equitable apportionment of respective fault among multiple defendants found strictly liable to the plaintiff. Since Walton has been reversed on this point by the Supreme Court, 530 Pa. 568, 610 A.2d 454 (1992), the verdict will be molded to reflect 20 percent liability for each of the five tortfeasors found responsible.
(3) The defendants claim a verdict of $250,000 for Mr.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit