Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court January 29, 1992 (Cohen v. Board of Water Commissioners, Fire District No. 1)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-01-1992

Liacos, C.J.

The board of water commissioners and the water department of .Fire District No. 1 in South Hadley3 appeal from a decision of the Land Court that the board’s regulations concerning the placement of water meters do not apply to the Hadley Village Condominium (Hadley Village). The Appeals Court summarily affirmed the Land Court decision. 30 Mass. App. Ct. 1107 (1991). We took this case for further appellate review. We hold that the regulations apply to Hadley Village, and reverse.

1. Factual and procedural history. In 1872, by special act, the General Court endowed Fire District No. 1 in South Hadley (District) with certain powers concerning the public water supply within its borders. St. 1872, c. 114, § 1. The District, which encompasses approximately two-thirds of the geographic area of the town of South Hadley, exercises its power through elected and appointed officials. Id. at §§ 6, 9. An elected board of water commissioners governs the District’s water supply and distribution system, and the water department manages and operates that system.

In 1954, and again in 1986, the board promulgated regulations regarding, inter alia, the placement of water meters. The 1954 regulations state that a “property owner must keep [a water] meter on his premises,” and rule 2-B-2 of the 1986 regulations requires each unit of a condominium to have its own water meter.4 Citing these regulations, on or about November 12, 1986, the board determined that a separate water *746meter would have to be installed in each unit of Hadley Village, a thirteen-building, 180-unit complex built prior to 1974, if it was converted from apartments to condominium units.5 The conversion occurred in 1987, but meters were not installed in the units.

In 1987, the trustees of the Hadley Village Condominium Trust, the governing body of the complex at the time, challenged the board’s regulations6 in the Land Court.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.