Massachusetts Appeals Court November 16, 1992, No. 90-P-1546 (Highland Tap of Boston, Inc. v. Commissioner of Consumer Affairs & Licensing)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-11-1992

Warner, C.J.

This case involves issues which have been in litigation since 1980. We begin by outlining the events that led to this appeal. The plaintiff Highland Tap of Boston, Inc. (Highland Tap), a tavern located on Washington Street in the Roxbury section of Boston, has held an entertainment license since the early 1970’s. It began to present nude dancing in September, 1979. In March of 1980, the licensing board of the city of Boston (board) held a hearing at which it asserted that the nude dancing violated G. L. c. 140, § 183A (as appearing in St. 1936, c. 71, § 1), the statute governing entertainment licensing, and that it also violated one of the board’s licensing regulations, then called condition 8A. At that time, condition 8A prohibited nudity on licensed premises unless the premises were located in the area known as the “Adult Entertainment Zone,” which had been so designated in 1974 by an amendment to the Boston Zoning Code.3 The board informed Highland Tap that it would defer action on the pending violation if Highland Tap stopped presenting nude dancing. The plaintiff had done so the month before, *561after being informed by the Boston police that the entertainment was illegal.

The Gargiulo Litigation.

In May of 1980, Highland Tap brought an action in the Superior Court, seeking to restrain the board from enforcing the licensing statute or condition 8A on grounds that they were unconstitutional facially and as applied. Highland Tap of Boston, Inc. vs. Gargiulo, Civil No. 42026 (Superior Court, Suffolk County, 1980) (hereafter Gargiulo). The court granted preliminary injunctive relief in June, 1980, and Highland Tap again began presenting nude entertainment. Since that time, Highland Tap has been permitted to present nude entertainment under court order.4

While Gargiulo was pending, a judge of the Federal District Court for Massachusetts held that G. L. c.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.