Court of Appeals of Washington August 10, 1992, No. 27573-9-I (Hendel v. Medley)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-08-1992

Webster, A.C.J.

James Medley appeals an order of the trial court finding him accountable to Douglas Hendel for payments made by Hendel on a note signed by both parties as "makers". Medley claims the trial court erred since the evidence establishes he signed as an "accommodation party". We agree and reverse.

Facts

In 1980, Medley (along with his wife Odette Trujillo) joined with Hendel to form the El Gaucho Restaurant (a subchapter S corporation). Medley and Trujillo were to hold a 45 percent interest as would Hendel (a silent partner held 10 percent); $278,000 was borrowed from Seafirst Bank with the shareholders serving as guarantors.

In 1982, after El Gaucho began experiencing financial difficulties, Seafirst refused to renew the loans. In September of 1982, financing was switched to First Interstate Bank in order to pay off the Seafirst loan. Trujillo, who had substantial sums of money available, loaned the corporation $91,035.46 in cash in return for a promissory note for $92,946.81. El Gaucho also executed a promissory note for the same amount in favor of Hendel on the premise Hendel would supply an equal amount of cash as that forwarded by Trujillo (apparently this was done to keep the contributions of the two families equal).

Hendel's contribution was to consist of funds borrowed from First Interstate. According to Medley, in order for Hendel to borrow these funds, First Interstate required Medley to sign the note as a co-maker. On November 1,1982, Hendel *898and Medley executed a promissory note in favor of First Interstate in the amount of $91,035.46. Upon receiving the money from First Interstate, it was turned over to the corporation to pay off the Seafirst loan. El Gaucho also executed a promissoiy note in favor of First Interstate in the amount of $83,964.54 dated November 1, 1982, and signed by Medley as president and Hendel as secretary.

The payments on the notes were to consist of profits earned by the corporation.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.