Louisiana Court of Appeal March 11, 1992, No. 90-1019 (Mitchell v. State ex rel. Department of Transportation & Development)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-03-1992

YELVERTON, Judge.

This appeal arises from an automobile accident that happened on a two lane section of Highway 1 in Rapides Parish at mid-morning on May 21, 1988. Willard Mitchell, his wife Earnestine, and a child, Tonia Richardson, were traveling south in their car. It was raining. Joseph Rachal’s automobile, Rachal driving northbound, crossed the centerline, and there was a collision.

Willard and Earnestine Mitchell suffered serious and permanent injuries. Earnestine is permanently paralyzed from the chest down and is confined to a wheelchair. Willard suffered a broken left hip, and he was blinded in his right eye.

The Mitchells sued Rachal and his insurer, Allstate Insurance Company, and the State of Louisiana through the DOTD. They alleged that a cause of the accident was the unreasonably dangerous condition of the highway, and that the DOTD had actual notice of the poor condition of the road and had ample opportunity to correct it.

After an extensive trial, the judge found the DOTD liable and awarded damages as follows:

Mrs. Mitchell:

General Damages.$ 500,000.00

Future Medical, equipment, therapy, medication & related needs.$3,176,000.00

Past Medical .$ 76,901.12

Impairment of earning capacity..$ 238,929.00

Barrier free living expenses_$ 94,000.00

TOTAL.$4,085,830.12

Mr. Mitchell:

General Damages.$ 500,000.00

Past and Future Lost Wages .. $ 274,271.00

Future Medical.$ 75,000.00

Past Medical .$ 39,557.48

TOTAL.$ 888,828.48

The state’s appeal attacks both the finding of liability and the award of damages.

The Mitchells answered the appeal contending that the trial court erred in finding that the claims of Earnestine’s minor children for loss of consortium were prescribed. They also complain by answer to the appeal that it was error not to rule that the state waived the cap of La.R.S. 13:5106 ($500,000 in general damages) by its failure to plead the cap as an affirmative defense.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.