Court of Civil Appeals of Alabama June 26, 1992, 2910242 (Smith v. Smith)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-06-1992

L. CHARLES WRIGHT, Retired Appellate Judge.

Robert Lee Smith and Lela Frances Smith were man and wife in February 1989. Robert filed suit for divorce in Marshall County, Alabama. The case was subsequently transferred to Calhoun County on motion of the wife. On February 21, 1991 an order was entered that the case would be dismissed unless a proper motion was filed within 15 days. Copies of the order were mailed to attorneys of record. On March 8, 1991 attorney for the husband applied to the register for entry of default. Default was entered. On May 29, 1991 a judgment of divorce was entered on default in favor of the husband. Lela Smith, on June 14, 1991, moved to set aside the default, averring that she had not been served with three days’ written notice of the application for default, as provided in Rule 55(b)(2), Alabama Rules of Civil Procedure. Hearing on the motion to set aside was held. Subsequently the court orally indicated that the motion would be granted. An order granting the motion to set aside the judgment was entered September 11, *10331991. Alas, Robert Smith had died on September 9, 1991.

A suggestion of death of Robert was filed by Lela Smith, and his son was appointed administrator ad litem of his father’s estate. Lela Smith filed another motion to set aside the default judgment, again charging violation of Rule 55(b)(2), A.R.Civ.P., and fraud in its procurement. She also alleged loss of property rights if the judgment were not set aside.

After a hearing, the court ordered the judgment set aside. Administrator ad li-tem (administrator) appealed. The issue presented on appeal is: Did the trial court err in setting aside the judgment in its entirety rather than modifying it in such a manner as to preserve any property rights of wife?

Administrator concedes that the wife apparently was not served with the written three-day notice required by Rule 55 before entry of the default judgment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.