Supreme Court of The Virgin Islands November 23, 1992, Civil No. 1047/1991 (Wilson v. Joseph)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-11-1992
CHRISTIAN, Senior Sitting Judge
MEMORANDUM OPINION
I. INTRODUCTION
Plaintiff, a month-to-month tenant of Defendant Landlord, sued Landlord for damages suffered by him when rented premises used as his residence flooded as a proximate result of incorrect connection of hose to septic tank by deceased Third-Party, the widower of the impleaded Third-Party Defendant. The Court dismissed the action against the Third-Party, holding that the proper Third-Party is the Estate of the decedent against whose estate claim for damages should be filed to test validity of claim. Since we find that Plaintiff's claim cannot legally lie against Defendant on the basis of either the doctrine of respondeat superior or negligent entrustment, and the damages suffered were the proximate result of the conduct of decedent who was an independent contractor supplying services not to common areas in the premises of landlord under landlord's control, we dismiss the action.
II. FACTS
Prior to the incident out of which this action arose, Plaintiff had been a month-to-month tenant of Defendant renting quarters at No. 174 Two Brothers, Frederiksted, St. Croix, for approximately two years at $200.00 a month. On many occasions, whenever there was a depletion of potable cistern water at the apartment, Defendant employed the husband of the Third-Party Defendant, now deceased, (hereafter "decedent"), who operated a water trucking supply business, to replenish the supply. There is no evidence that decedent was ever less than careful, prudent and businesslike in either his services to Defendant or to other clients either in performing this service or in any other activity.
On or about June 20,1990, the Defendant employed the decedent to replenish the water supply at Plaintiff's residence.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit