Richmond County Circuit Court May 21, 1992, Case No. LU-781-4 (Smith v. Ellis)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-05-1992

By Judge Randall G. Johnson

This medical malpractice case is before the court on three of the four defendants’ statute of limitations pleas. After a hearing on April 17, the court ruled from the bench that the pleas would be sustained and that the three defendants making the pleas would be dismissed. By letter to counsel dated April 24, however, and before an order had been entered on the court’s ruling, the court informed counsel that it was having second thoughts about its ruling and would like to hear further argument. Another hearing was held on May 18.

The events giving rise to plaintiff’s claim occurred no later than November 8, 1989. A notice of claim was mailed to one of the defendants, Robert Ellis, M.D., on October 30, 1991. On November 5, 1991, a second notice of claim, this time naming all four defendants, was hand-delivered and mailed to each defendant. In addition to including the three additional defendants, the second notice of claim also contained two allegations of negligence which were not included in the first notice. The three defendants who were not named in the first notice of claim argue, and the court initially held, that Va. Code § 8.01-581.2:1 precluded the second notice from having any legal significance and that, accordingly, such second notice did not toll the running of the two-year statute of limitations as to the three added defendants. Section 8.01-581.2:1 provides:

Amendment of notice of claim .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.