Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit January 10, 1992, Nos. 166, 294, Dockets 91-7426, -7496 (181 East 73rd Street Co. v. 181 East 73rd Tenants Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-01-1992

OAKES, Chief Judge:

We must decide in this appeal to whom Congress accorded the right to terminate a self-dealing lease pursuant to section 3607 of the Condominium and Cooperative Abuse Relief Act of 1980, 15 U.S.C. §§ 3601-3616 (1988) (“Abuse Relief Act”) and who may waive that right. The case arises from a conversion of a twenty-story building, located at 181 East 73rd Street in Manhattan, from rental property to cooperative ownership. The building contains 116 apartments and street-level commercial property, including three stores, a restaurant, and a parking garage. Plaintiff 181 East 73rd Street Co. (“Sponsor”), the former owner of the building, sponsored the *46conversion,1 and defendant 181 East 73rd Tenants Corporation (“Tenants Corporation”) acquired title to the building. As part of the conversion plan, Tenants Corporation — still controlled by officers and directors appointed by Sponsor — executed a ninety-nine year Master Lease that demised the commercial property back to the Sponsor.

The shareholders of Tenants Corporation subsequently voted to terminate, pursuant to section 3607 of the Abuse Relief Act, the portion of the Master Lease that covered the fifty-two car parking garage. Sponsor brought a declaratory judgment action challenging the validity of the termination on the grounds that Tenants Corporation had waived its termination right.2 In addition, Sponsor sought damages and rent reduction. Tenants Corporation counterclaimed, seeking attorneys’ fees and a declaratory judgment as to both the validity of the termination of the garage portion of the Master Lease and the unconscionability of the entire Master Lease under New York law. Both parties moved for summary judgment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.