Court of Appeals of South Carolina May 17, 1993, 2013 (City of North Charleston v. Claxton)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-05-1993

Gardner, Judge:

The City of North Charleston (the City) commenced a condemnation proceeding against landowners Janie and William Claxton (the Claxtons). The Claxtons requested a jury trial to determine the value of the condemned property. The jury returned a verdict for the Claxtons for $79,500. The City made a motion for new trial nisi and the Claxtons moved for an award of attorney fees. The trial judge denied the motion for new trial and awarded the Claxtons $17,654.15 in attorney fees. Both parties appeal. We affirm.

FACTS

In 1985 Centre Pointe announced plans for a private 394-acre development at the intersection of 1-26 and Mark Clark Expressway in North Charleston. Centre Pointe originally planned to build the Centre Pointe Mall with peripheral commercial properties. In connection with this plan, Centre Pointe donated 32 acres to the City conditioned upon the City’s obligation to build a coliseum on the property within seven years after the gift. Under this original plan, the Claxtons’ property was not needed for the City’s Project, including the coliseum. The Claxtons’ property, one of nine lots, adjoined one property line of the future Centre Pointe Mall.

The Army Corps of Engineers issued a cease and desist order that stopped construction of the Centre Pointe private development. Approximately half of the private development was in wetlands. The property donated to the City, however, was highland not subject to the cease and desist order. Centre Pointe developers negotiated a settlement with the Corps of Engineers that would allow Centre Pointe to continue its private development. A cornerstone of this settlement was a requirement that the City not build its project on the 32 acres of highland donated by Centre Pointe.

The City agreed to a land swap provided it received a suitable 32-acre site on what had been Centre Pointe’s private development under the original plan.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.