District Court, D. Utah July 21, 1993, 1:93-cv-00069 (United States v. Sandoval)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-07-1993

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

ALDON J. ANDERSON, Senior District Judge.

I. Introduction

This matter is before the court on defendant Miguel Sandoval’s motions to suppress evidence and statements. An evidentiary hearing was held on June 11,1993, and arguments of counsel were heard on June 28, 1993

1

. Between the evidentiary hearing and arguments, the court viewed Plaintiffs Exhibit 1, a video tape taken of the traffic stop and subsequent arrest of defendant, Miguel Sandoval.

2

Sandoval argues that evidence of cocaine found in his vehicle by the Utah Highway Patrol should be suppressed because the initial traffic stop of Sandoval was merely a pretext for undertaking a search. Further, Sandoval argues that the evidence should be suppressed because he was illegally -detained in violation of the Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution. Finally, in support of the motion to suppress evidence, Sandoval argues that any consent he gave to search was not informed or voluntary, and even if informed and voluntary, that the consent was limited in scope which was exceeded by the government.

Sandoval also asks the court to suppress incriminating statements made by Sandoval, in the course of the traffic stop and arrest, because the government failed to give a Miranda warning at the time of his arrest.

Having reviewed the evidence, and considered the arguments of counsel, the court is persuaded that the cocaine and Sandoval were properly seized, and that evidence of the cocaine should not be suppressed. However, the court is also persuaded that incriminating statements made by Sandoval, subse

*358

quent to his arrest and prior to his receiving a Miranda warning, must be suppressed.

II. Facts

On March 22, 1993, Utah Highway Patrolman Jim Hillin stopped a pickup being driven by Miguel Sandoval. The evidence is clear that the stop was made for speeding (71-73 mph in a 65 mph zone), and that Hillin was acting as he would normally have done in carrying out his responsibilities.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.