Missouri Court of Appeals January 12, 1993, 62708 (Leritz v. Koehr)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-01-1993
CARL R. GAERTNER, Presiding Judge.
This is prohibition.
Respondent circuit judge denied relator’s motion to quash notices of depositions of custodians of certain medical records. Relator seeks oiu* writ prohibiting respondent from enforcing his order and commanding the vacation thereof. We issued a preliminary writ which we now make permanent.
The underlying action is a suit for damages resulting from alleged medical malpractice. The allegedly negligent physician died prior to the commencement of the litigation, and relator was named as defendant ad litem pursuant to § 537.021.1(2) RSMo.1986. Plaintiffs propounded several interrogatories to relator who responded to each interrogatory “I do not know the answer thereto.” Counsel for defendant ad litem then forwarded to plaintiffs’ counsel “Answers By Defendant’s Counsel, Not Under Oath, To Plaintiff’s Interrogatories Propounded To Defendant, Made For Purposes Of Facilitating The Litigation.” In these answers relator’s counsel advised that the deceased doctor on the day after plaintiff’s surgery was himself admitted to a hospital suffering from the effects of multiple sclerosis. The answer included the names of physicians who treated the deceased doctor and hospitals in which he had received treatment. Plaintiffs’ attorney then served notices to take depositions of the custodians of the records of these doctors and hospitals. Relator moved to quash these notices claiming the disclosure of the records would violate the physician-patient privilege. Respondent overruled this motion “for the reason that the court rules any medical privilege between the deceased Dr. Dean Smith and the various healthcare providers does not survive the death of the patient.” Relator then filed his application for our writ prohibiting the enforcement of respondent’s order and commanding the vacation thereof.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit