Kentucky Supreme Court February 18, 1993, Nos. 92-SC-439-T, 92-SC-550-T (State Board for Elementary & Secondary Education v. Ball)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-02-1993

STEPHENS, Chief Justice.

The issue presented by this case is whether the State Board for Elementary and Secondary Education (hereinafter State Board), under the Kentucky Education Reform Act (hereinafter KERA), has the authority to remove members from a county board of education for misconduct in office. If it is determined that the State Board has such authority, we must then determine whether the evidence in this case supports a judgment of removal by the State Board.

Ronnie G. Ball, Benny Dale Coleman and David Lewis were members of the Harlan County Board of Education. In November 1991, Dr. Thomas C. Boysen, Kentucky’s chief state school officer, recommended the removal of Ball, Coleman and Lewis from the Harlan County Board of Education for their alleged misconduct in office. After *744they waived the right to a summary suspension hearing, a removal hearing was set for January 18, 1992. After four days of lengthy hearings, the State Board unanimously voted to remove Ball, Coleman and Lewis from the Harlan County Board of Education, effective immediately.

The removal of Ball, Coleman and Lewis left only two members remaining on the Harlan County Board. Because three members are required for a quorum, the State Board, pursuant to KRS 156.070(1), voted to accept the day-to-day responsibilities for the Harlan County Schools.

Ball, Coleman and Lewis appealed their removal to the Harlan Circuit Court. KRS 156.132(8). On May 28, 1992, Harlan Circuit Judge Ron Johnson entered a “Final Order and Decision” in which he rendered a decision in favor of Ball, Coleman and Lewis.

The State Board sought emergency and intermediate relief in the Court of Appeals. On June 4, 1992, the Court of Appeals granted intermediate relief holding that interim management and control remained vested in the State Board.

On June 2, 1992, the Harlan Circuit Court entered an “Amended Final Order and Decision” and “Order” correcting typographical errors in the first Order.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.