Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York March 29, 1993 (In re Luz P.)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-03-1993

OPINION OF THE COURT

Sullivan, J. P.

In this child protective proceeding we consider the proper course to be taken by a trial court when confronted with a potential witness who suffers from a disability in communicating. Luz P. is an 11-year-old girl who is nonverbal and has been described as both autistic and mentally retarded. She has *276been enrolled in a "BOCES” special education program for the developmentally disabled in Orange County. It does not appear that Luz has any hearing defect.

In February 1992 therapists in the special education program claimed that Luz could communicate with them by means of "facilitated communication”. In this process, Luz allegedly communicates by spelling out words on a keyboard while a "facilitator” supports her hand. Using this technique, the teachers contend that Luz has demonstrated an understanding of both English and Spanish and an ability to read, spell, and tell time. In the course of communicating with her teachers, it is claimed that Luz alleged that her parents were sexually abusing her. As a result of this information, the Orange County Department of Social Services (hereinafter the DSS) removed Luz from the custody of her parents on May 12, 1992. On the following day, DSS filed a petition in the Family Court, Orange County, pursuant to Family Court Act article 10 alleging that both parents had sexually abused Luz.

On May 14, 1992, the parents appeared to answer the petition in Family Court. Attorneys were appointed for each of them and a Spanish interpreter was provided. The court entered an order placing Luz in the temporary custody of the DSS. The parents have never sought the return of Luz pursuant to Family Court Act § 1028.

A fact-finding hearing was to commence on October 22, 1992, in the Family Court, Orange County. The County Attorney representing the DSS sought to call the child Luz as his first witness.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.