New York Supreme Court November 23, 1993 (Chatham Towers, Inc. v. Estate of Tom)

*891OPINION OF THE COURT

Beverly S. Cohen, J.

In this declaratory judgment action, Chatham Towers, a private residential cooperative (the Coop), seeks a summary judgment declaration with respect to defendants’ respective rights to certain Coop shares of stock allocable to apartment 12E of Towers I located at 170 Park Row in lower Manhattan (the Apartment).