District Court, C.D. Illinois December 29, 1993, No. 89-3022 (State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance v. W.R. Grace & Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-12-1993
ORDER
RICHARD MILLS, District Judge:
This cause is before the Court on State Farm’s motion to enforce this Court’s order of June 4, 1993 regarding the cost of retaking John Walsh’s deposition.
During trial, State Farm moved to exclude W.R. Grace’s damages expert, John Walsh, from testifying about numerous new opinions he was going to give at trial since he was unable to discuss them at his deposition. On June 4,1993, the Court ruled that Mr. Walsh would be permitted to testify about his late-formed opinions, but that State Farm would be permitted to depose Mr. Walsh “at no cost to the plaintiff, at all, State Farm.” Tr. at 7580.
At issue in this motion is whether W.R. Grace should now pay for all State Farm’s expenses associated with the deposition of Mr. Walsh, including attorney and paralegal fees and out of pocket expenses.
1. Attorney and Paralegal Fees
W.R. Grace’s position is that it should not pay for attorney or paralegal fees for the retaking of the Walsh deposition.
The Court agrees.
By using the term “costs,” (“at no cost to the plaintiff, at all, State Farm”) the Court was referring to the “costs” statutorily authorized by 28 U.S.C. § 1920. Attorneys fees and paralegal fees are not authorized by 28 U.S.C. § 1920. ■ The Court regrets any misunderstanding our language may have created. Nonetheless, State Farm should have confirmed that attorneys fees were to be included in our verbal order before expending an exorbitant amount of time (51.25 hours of attorney preparation—not including *848actual time spent attending the deposition) in deposing Mr. Walsh for the third time.
Accordingly, State Farm’s request for $20,188.75 in fees is denied.
2. “Out of Pocket” Expenses
W.R. Grace next objects to the travel, hotel, and meal expenses for Lisa Funston, the paralegal who attended the Walsh depositions. W.R. Grace argues that attendance of Ms. Funston at the deposition was not necessary.
The Court agrees.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit