West Virginia Supreme Court November 18, 1994, 22206 (Painter v. Peavy)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-11-1994

CLECKLEY, Justice:

This civil action was brought for damages arising out of an automobile collision. Annette J. Painter, the appellant and plaintiff below, appeals an order of the Circuit Court of Mercer County, entered September 7, 1993, which granted summary judgment in favor of Patrick Devolta Peavy, the appellee and defendant below. The circuit court found that an accord and satisfaction was reached between the parties when the plaintiff deposited a check from the defendant’s insurance company tendered “[f]or full settlement of all claims,” irrespective of the notation “[deposited under protest” by the endorsement. The plaintiff contends that summary judgment was inappropriate because genuine issues of material fact exist. We disagree with the plaintiffs argument and affirm the order of the circuit court.

I.

The record shows that on September 17, 1989, the plaintiff was injured when the car she was driving was struck by the defendant’s car. Garland Spangler, an attorney in Virginia, originally represented the plaintiff.

1

Receipts of medical bills totalling $708.60 were submitted to the defendant’s insurer, Colonial Insurance Company of California (Colonial). A check for $750, dated January 31, 1990, was mailed to the plaintiff. The check stated “for full settlement of all claims.” The claims examiner stated that the check was intended to settle the injury claim.

2

In February, 1990, Mr. Spangler notified a claims adjuster for Colonial that the plaintiff rejected the settlement offer of $750. Affidavits of two Colonial claims examiners reveal that after Mr. Spangler rejected the settlement offer, he was instructed to return the check to Colonial. Colonial did not, however, stop payment of the check. The check was endorsed and it was deposited in Mr. Span-gler’s account in March, 1990. “Deposited under protested” was written on the back of the check.

The plaintiff stated in her affidavit that she had no contact whatsoever with Colonial nor with the defendant.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.